YASIR QADHI, MUHAMMAD & TABUK

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun

Table of Contents

In this post I will be quoting from the sirah produced by noted Muslim scholar Yasir Qadhi in respect to Muhammad’s expedition against Tabuk. I do so since Qadhi does a fine job of refuting the oft-repeated lie that the reason why Muhammad sent his jihadis to kill this Byzantine stronghold is because the Byzantines were planning to send an army to attack the Muslims. Qadhi shows that this is nothing more than Islamic propaganda since the Byzantines had no intention of doing so, but rather it was simply another case of Muhammad’s lust and greed that motivated him to send out an expedition to subjugate another group of unsuspecting victims. All emphasis will be mine.

The Expedition of Tabuk took place in Rajab 9 AH and was the last expedition in the sirah of the Prophet. It was also the furthest the Prophet ever travelled with an army. The purpose of the expedition IS NOT ENTIRELY CLEAR, but scholars offer theories.

Some explain that the Romans were preparing a large army to attack the Muslims after the Chieftain of the Ghassanids sent a letter to Rome urging their support.1003 However, it may be FAR-FETCHED for the Roman Empire to send thousands of troops to the Arabs.

Another theory explains that the Ghassanids themselves were the target of the attack,1004 which is perhaps more plausible. However, it would not explain why the Prophet would embark in the hottest month of the year, which–as will be explained below–caused extreme hardship. The MOST CONCEIVABLE EXPLANATION, therefore, is that it was a command from Allah to test the believers.

The subtext of the expedition, in any case, was A PRE-EMPTIVE ATTACK ON ROMAN FORCES, and the Muslims were expecting a formidable foe.

The Expedition of Tabuk comprised the biggest army in the whole sirah, with sources claiming over 30,000 attendees.1003 This may be an overestimation due to the enormous crowds and the impossible task of counting them.

The expedition took place in the scorching heat of summer, which is particularly severe in Arabia. The desert climate further exacerbated the heat, which grew almost unbearable. The Companions endured this for an entire month, as they travelled for over 1,000 miles.

Moreover, the Prophet embarked just before the harvest season. Most people did not enjoy a regular salary; rather, they earned their income on a yearly basis according to their harvest. The army left before the harvest and returned after the harvest, effectively forgoing an entire year’s income. (The Sirah of the Prophet: A Contemporary Analysis, adapted and edited by Dr. Salah Sharief [Wordsmith Press, 2nd edition, 2024], Part IV: The Medinan Era, 27: The Expedition of Tabuk, pp. 378-379)  

And:

The Expedition of Tabuk was a personal obligation (fard ‘ayn)i on every Muslim, as the Prophet explicitly commanded every capable adult male to attend. Moreover, the entirety of Surah al-Tawbah was revealed, which is the most direct surah in urging jihad.  Allah states, “O believers! What is the matter with you that when you are asked to march forth in the cause of Allah, you cling firmly to [your] land? Do you prefer the life of this world over the Hereafter? The enjoyment of this worldly life is insignificant compared to that of the Hereafter. If you do not march forth, He will afflict you with a painful torment and replace you with other people. You are not harming Him in the least. And Allah is Most Capable of everything.”1009   

These strong commands corroborate the theory that the Expedition of Tabuk was a test from Allah, as the same type of language is not used in any other surah when encouraging Jihad. It was the final expedition with the Prophet, and Allah wanted to test the believers’ sincerity to the cause. The fact that NO FIGHTING took place but the expedition itself was extremely testing further adds to the notion that it was all a test.

i Islamic obligations are categorized into two: personal obligations (fard ‘ayn) and communal obligations (fard kifayah). Personal obligations, such as prayer and fasting, are mandated upon every single Muslim as long as they meet the requirements of the obligation. Communal obligations are required of a community, and once the obligation is fulfilled, the community is absolved of the responsibility. Examples include the Friday Sermon and the funeral prayer–if no-one performs these obligations, the whole community is deemed sinful, but if someone does, the community is absolved. (Ibid., 380)  

Muhammad even promised his murdering jihadis light-skinned Roman women as sex booty in order to entice them to go out and murder the people of Tabuk!

The Hypocrites also gave pitiful excuses not to attend the expedition both before and after. The Prophet asked al-Jadd ibn Qays, a notable Hypocrite and friend of ‘Abdullah ibn Ubayy, why he was not attending, to which he said, “O Messenger of Allah, can you not excuse me? By Allah, my people know that I have a weakness for women, and I am afraid that if I see the Roman women that I would not be able to control myself.”1015 Allah revealed, “There are some of them who say, ‘Exempt me and do not expose me to temptation.’ They have already fallen into temptation. And Hell will surely engulf the disbelievers.”1016 (Ibid., p. 382)

FURTHER READING

Here Comes The Blondes!

A “Prophet” for Profit: More of Muhammad’s Inconsistencies Exposed

The Byzantine Christians: Antagonists or Antagonized? Pt. 1, Pt. 2

MUHAMMAD: THE ANTAGONIZING WAR-MONGER

Muhammad and the Meccans: Who Antagonized Whom?

Muhammad the Antagonist Still!

Is the Jihad of Q. 9:29 Defensive in Nature?

“Kill those who Associate Partners (Mushrikun) Wherever You Find Them!”

The Myth of Islamic Tolerance  

Is Islam a religion of Peace?

Should Muslims Accept Peace or Not?

Fighting All People Until They Do What?

Compel them or Not?

The Meaning and Purpose of Paying Jizyah

PLIGHT OF NON-MUSLIMS IN AN ISLAMIC STATE

The Mistreatment and Degradation of the People of the Book

MUHAMMAD AND THE JEWS

islamhistoryquranhadithsunnahpolitics2025

Comments


Get Updates