responses

Detailed responses to Islamic assertions, critiques, and controversies, offering thorough scriptural and historical counter-arguments.

Is Mary the Sister of Aaron? Members Public

IS MARY THE SISTER OF AARON? by Silas ABSTRACT Muhammad was confused about Jesus' mother's identity. In the Quran he erred by identifying her as Aaron's sister. When presented with this error Muhammad created an ad hoc explanation to cover his mistake. This paper explains

Silas
maryjesusislam

Responses to Bismikaallahuma: An Alleged Correction of Mark by Matthew and Luke Members Public

Responses to Bismikaallahuma Helms and the Prologue of Mark Sam Shamoun MENJ published today a short critique of the Gospels, claiming that Mark made a mistake in his prologue(*). Mark quotes Isaiah 40:3 and Malachi 3:1, "mistakenly" attributing them both to Isaiah. The Muslim author then

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
biblegospelmatthew

Revisiting the issue of Muhammads marital privileges Members Public

Responding to a Muslim Dawagandists defense of his prophets blatant inconsistencies Sam Shamoun This is a continuation of our series of replies (*) to Jalal Abualrubs material (*) which he produced for his debate with Christian philosopher and apologist David Wood (1, 2, 3). Jalal comes to Muhammads defense by trying to

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
allahislamquran

A Response to many of Osama Abdallah's Mantras Members Public

A Response to many of Osama Abdallah's Mantras Osama has taken aim at my answer to his gross errors regarding Luke 23:34. It is quite clear from Osamas response that he was unable to address the issues, but chose instead to bring up irrelevant points and logical

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamislam-rebuttalsresponses

Rebuttal to Akbarally Meherally : The Lord of Retribution Members Public

Responses to Akbarally Meherally's site The Lord of Retribution After the quotation of several claims from the Quran, Meherally begins his article with this statement: Political Posturing and False Claims: The arrogant and unjust Jews and Christians claim that the Holy Land of the Middle East had been

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamallahquran

Rebuttals to Islamic Awareness : Some Logical Fallacies Dealt with in the Qur'an Members Public

Responses to Islamic Awareness Some Logical Fallacies Dealt with in the Qur'an Introduction Professor Mir tells us that the Qur'an appeals to the intellect over emotions, especially when this book points out the fallacious arguments of those people and nations who opposed the Prophets or, in

Andrew Vargo
quranislamislam-rebuttals

Jalal Abualrub's "pack of lies" Members Public

Ignorance or Deception? It is a regular feature of Abualrub's propaganda articles to call all those LIARS who dare to express an opinion that is annoying to Abualrub. In my view, that is an absolutely unacceptable behavior, and I have informed him about this in private communication. In

Jochen Katz
islamislam-rebuttalsresponses

Responses to Bismikaallahuma: Hans Kng On Is Muhammad A Prophet? Members Public

Responses to Bismika Allahuma Hans Küng On "Is Muhammad A Prophet?" Introduction On 23 December 2005, the Muslim website Bismika Allahuma republished an article by Hans Küng stating his opinion that Christians should move towards acknowledging Muhammad as a prophet of God. On 29 December 2005, I published

Jochen Katz
islamprophecytheology
Get Updates