islam

In-depth analysis of Islamic theology, scripture, tradition, and argumentation through rigorous scholarly critique.

Comments on Abdul Wahid's Pages Members Public

Some comment on Abdul Wahid's paper Divinity of Jesus. Much more could be said, but maybe at another time. So, the Muslim seeks clarification of the teaching, and as it is explained to him he asks at every step, "How could that be so?" For example,

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
jesus-christtrinitychristianity

Responses to Bismikaallahuma: The Invalidity of a Critic's Denial of Christian Atonement Theology Members Public

Responses to Bismikaallahuma The Invalidity of a Critic's Denial of Christian Atonement Theology Wildcat Introduction On MENJs site we find the article, The Invalidity of the Crucifixion of Jesus As An Atonement for Sin, attributed to a retired physicist and practicing Jew, named Dr. JosephG. The author attempts

Wildcat
atonementchristianitytheology

On using Atheist sources in Muslim-Christian debates Members Public

Responses to Bismikaallahuma Being stupid or playing stupid? On using atheist sources Mohd Elfie Nieshaem Juferi (MENJ) thinks that he finally caught us ... and wrote the article Answering Islam: Preaching What They Do Not Practise?[1] In this polemic, he charges us with hypocrisy for violating our own policy statement,

Jochen Katz
islamchristianitytheology

The Death of Asma and Abu Afak: Does the Quran Prohibit the Killing of Mockers? Members Public

The Death of Asma and Abu Afak Does the Quran Prohibit the Killing of Mockers? Sam Shamoun In this second part (cf. Part 1) we will seek to interact with some of the typical Muslim polemics used to deny the veracity of the Islamic reports that mention Muhammad ordering the

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamquranhadith

The Death of Asma and Abu Afak: Examining the Historical Basis for these Murders Members Public

The Death of Asma and Abu Afak Examining the Historical Basis for these Murders Sam Shamoun Introduction Muhammad didnt like people to mock or satirize him and had several persons killed for it. Two of the individuals who were murdered at the orders of Muhammad were a 120-year-old Jewish man

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamhadithhistory

The Murder of Asma Bint Marwan Revisited Members Public

Exposing the Distortions of one Muslim Dawagandist Sam Shamoun In his recent debate with David Wood (Is Muhammad a Prophet? (04/12/2008); source) Jalal Abualrub claimed that his opponent was using fraudulent narratives to impugn Muhammads character, such as the stories of his prophet having Abu Afak and Asma

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamresponsesislam-rebuttals

Responses to "Arabic Paper" Members Public

Comments on Arabic Paper 's site " Islam Answers " Arabic Paper has quite a number of vitriolic and hateful articles on their site "Islam Answers" originally titled "Enemies of Islam" for the first several months. Even some Muslims are not thinking very highly of

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
responsesislam-rebuttalsislam

Rebuttals to Islamic Awareness Members Public

Responses to Islamic Awareness Christian Analysis of the Islamic Awareness' Alleged Rebuttal to: Prophet Muhammad's Night Journey To Al-Masjid Al-Aqs - The Farthest Mosque Sam Shamoun The following is an examination of the claims set forth by Islamic Awareness in trying to save the Quran from a

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamislam-rebuttalsresponses
Get Updates