hadith

Critical examinations of hadith literature, transmission, contradictions, reliability, and theological implications in Islam.

Did the Meccans Believe in Allah as the Most High? Members Public

Addressing the Claims of Muslim Polemicists On the Issue of Allah and Hubal Sam Shamoun Islamic Awareness seeks to address my claim that the hadith regarding Abu Sufyan crediting Hubal with his victory over the Muslims demonstrates that the pre-Islamic pagans considered that their gods were equal to, if

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
allahislamquran

Hubal and Allah Members Public

Hubal and Allah Revisited Addressing one Muslim Polemicist’s Denials Sam Shamoun Muslim writer and polemicist MENJ has undertaken the task of responding to my article regarding the identity of Allah as Hubal in pre-Islamic Arabia. The readers can see our discussion of this issue here, and MENJ’s

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
allahislamhistory

Because they do not know what they are talking about Members Public

Islam and homosexuality? ... for they do not know what they are talking about! Bismikaallahuma has tried to deal with my refutation of Asif Iqbal’s slanders against God’s true prophets, specifically his assertion that Daniel was a homosexual. The author of this particular response article goes by the name

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamquranhadith

Osama Abdallah's reaction to "Muhammad's False Prophecies" [Part 3] Members Public

Osama Abdallah's reaction to Muhammad's False Prophecies [Part 3] Sam Shamoun [Read first Part 1 and Part 2.] This is the third part of our rebuttal series to Osama Abdullah, whose article can be found here. Osama begins: My response: Even though I agree with the

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamprophecyIslamic Prophecy

Osama Abdallah's reaction to "Muhammad's False Prophecies" [Part 2] Members Public

Osama Abdallah's reaction to Muhammad's False Prophecies [Part 2] Sam Shamoun [Read first Part 1] Osama continues: The predictions of a Prophet appearing with a host of "ten thousand saints" are repeated in the New Testament. RESPONSE: As we have already documented, there is

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamhadithquran

Osama Abdallah's reaction to "Muhammad's False Prophecies" [Part 1] Members Public

Osama Abdallah's reaction to Muhammad's False Prophecies [Part 1] Sam Shamoun The following is our first response to Osama's attempted "rebuttal" to my article. Before beginning our rebuttal something needs to be said about Osama's work. Osama's material

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamIslamic Prophecyhadith

Osama Abdallah: Spreading Hoaxes for the Advancement of Islam? Members Public

Gullibility or Intention? Osama Abdallah — Champion of Hoaxes in the Name of Islam The confidence in the truth of Islam, for many Muslims, appears to be based for a good part on the conviction that modern science confirms the Qur'an. They believe, and want to make us believe,

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamquranhadith

Rebuttals to Islamic Awareness : On The Nature Of Hadith Collections Of Imam Bukhari & Muslim Members Public

Responses to Islamic Awareness On The Nature Of Hadth Collections Of Imm Bukhr & Muslim In a recent article, Khazraj, Ghoniem, Saifullah, and Hannan [who for the sake of brevity, will be referred to as KGSH] objected to a response that I wrote entitled Are There any Early Hadith? A

Andrew Vargo
islamhadithsunnah
Get Updates