hadith

Critical examinations of hadith literature, transmission, contradictions, reliability, and theological implications in Islam.

"Who Was Muhammad?" -- A Review of the Debate between David Wood and Ali Ataie Members Public

"Who Was Muhammad?" A Debate between David Wood and Ali Ataie By Mary Jo Sharp (Confident Christianity) The main objective of this debate was to take a critical look at the prophet of Islam, Muhammad. David Wood, the Christian apologist, began the debate with a warning that "

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamquranhadith

The David Wood vs. Nadir Ahmed Debate Members Public

Islams Next Great Hope or Dope? An Analysis of the David Wood vs. Nadir Ahmed Debate Sam Shamoun Christian apologist David Wood debated Nadir Ahmed on the topic, "God: Trinity or Tauheed" (*). It is not our purpose to offer an assessment of the debate itself.(1) Rather, we

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
christianityislamquran

Rebuttals to Islamic Awareness Members Public

Responses to Islamic Awareness Hadth From Sunan ad-Drimi Concerning Prophet Moses(P) Following Prophet Muhammad(P) If The Former Were Alive Today by Muhammad Ghoniem Refutation Of The Christian Missionary Writing Ghoniem attempts to deal with my response to his paper, but as we shall see has failed to deal

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamquranhadith

Rebuttals to Islamic Awareness Members Public

Responses to Islamic Awareness Hadth From Sunan ad-Drimi Concerning Prophet Moses(P) Following Prophet Muhammad(P) If The Former Were Alive Today Presumably, Ghoniem's article is trying to establish the point that since Moses' teachings have been superseded by the teachings of Muhammad, this serves to prove

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamquranhadith

Shabir Ally and the crucified Messiah Members Public

by Anders Nissen October 19 2000 a debate was held between Shabir Ally and Jay Smith on the truth about Jesus (see http://www.facultylinc.com/national/fslf.nsf). Is it the Quran or the Bible that presents the true Jesus? Jay Smith opened the debate by presenting reasons for

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
jesusjesus-christgospel

Rebuttals to "Islamic Information" : Biblical Criticism Members Public

Responses to "Islamic Information" Biblical Criticism The word "criticism" is often taken by the public to imply negative judgment. Hence "biblical criticism" is often taken to mean negative judgment against the Bible. Yet it is not necessary to gather this meaning from the use

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamquranhadith

The Islamic Concept of Corporate Justice Members Public

More Evidence of One Muslims Blatant Inconsistency Sam Shamoun The Objection Muslim polemicist Shabir Ally has written several articles addressing and interacting with Dr. James R. Whites comments regarding their recent debate in Seattle, Washington, concerning the topic, "Was Jesus Christ Crucified as a Willing Sacrifice for the Sins

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamtheologyallah

Muslim Responses to Jay Smith's Papers Members Public

The material by Jay Smith has caused quite some reaction in the Muslim real and cyber world. In particular his paper on the historical critique of the Qur'an. Since most of the Muslim sites that attack the evidence and interpretation presented by Jay Smith do not link to

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamislam-rebuttalsresponses
Get Updates