hadith

Critical examinations of hadith literature, transmission, contradictions, reliability, and theological implications in Islam.

Bassam Zawadi on Muhammad's Treaty of Hudaibiyah Members Public

Bassam Zawadi on Muhammad's Treaty of Hudaibiyah Sam Shamoun Bassam Zawadi attempts to do some damage control by justifying Muhammads breaking of treaties and oaths. Zawadi responds to Silas claim that Muhammad broke the treaty of Hudaibiyah by refusing to return a woman from Mecca back to her

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamhistorysunnah

Muhammads Cruelty Reexamined Members Public

Muhammads Cruelty Reexamined Being a Challenge to a Muslim Polemicist Sam Shamoun Bassam Zawadi was very troubled at the fact that his prophet tortured a man for some treasure: My Response: Many anti Islamics have used this incident of the torture of Kinana to attack the integrity of the Prophet.

Silas
islamquranhadith

Prostration as evidence of corruption? Members Public

Sam Shamoun Bassam Zawadi has produced a rather lengthy paper (*) attempting to disprove the claim that the Quran and the so-called authentic Islamic narratives confirm the authority and textual reliability of the Holy Bible. {Side note: It is rather amusing to see that the title that Zawadi chose for

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamislam-rebuttalsresponses

Who Broke the Covenant: Paul or Muhammad? Members Public

Sam Shamoun Bassam Zawadi claims (1, 2) that Paul broke the covenant of God: Paul broke the covenant of God regarding circumcision. God of the Old Testament says about circumcision... Genesis 17:14 Any uncircumcised male, who has not been circumcised in the flesh, will be cut off from his

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamislam-rebuttalsresponses

Barra: Juwayriyyahs Original Name or Nickname? Members Public

More Groans for Zawadi Sam Shamoun In an earlier article we referred to Muhammad taking a Jewish captive woman as his wife and then cited this report: Ibn Abbas reported that the name of Juwairiya (the wife of the Holy Prophet) was Barra (Pious). Allah's Messenger (may peace

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamquranhadith

Is Allah in need of sinful people? Members Public

Allah's Need For Sinners Sam Shamoun Bassam Zawadi wrote a rebuttal (1, 2) to a specific article which uses a common philosophical argument to support Gods Triunity and self-sufficiency, namely that God is love. It is not the aim of this paper to critique Zawadis response so

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
allahislamhadith

"Was Muhammad a Prophet of God?" : Responses to Sami Zaatari’s Debate Points [Part 2] Members Public

"Was Muhammad a Prophet of God?" Responses to Sami Zaatari’s Debate Points [Part 2] Sam Shamoun As promised we resume our analysis of Sami’s debate points. As far as Muhammad initially believing that he was demon-possessed Sami responded by appealing to the fact that Muhammad

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamquranhadith

"Was Muhammad a Prophet of God?" : Responses to Sami Zaataris Debate Points [Part 1] Members Public

"Was Muhammad a Prophet of God?" Responses to Sami Zaataris Debate Points [Part 1] Sam Shamoun Just recently, a group of Christians engaged several Muslims in a series of debates on March 21-23, 2008 titled "the Easter Debates" (*). Some of the debate participants included our

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamquranhadith
Get Updates