hadith

Critical examinations of hadith literature, transmission, contradictions, reliability, and theological implications in Islam.

Qur'an Contradiction: Were Believers Called Muslims Before the Time of Muhammad? Members Public

Confusion and/or Errors in the Qur'an? Were Believers Really Called Muslims Before the Time of Muhammad? The following article is a work in progress. My thoughts are not yet finalized on every issue that I am going to raise. I want to invite the feedback and thoughts

Jochen Katz
islamquranQur’anic Contradictions

Contradiction Regarding Muhammads Fatherhood: An Examination of The Quran and Islamic Tradition Members Public

Contradiction Regarding Muhammads Fatherhood An Examination of The Quran and Islamic Tradition Sam Shamoun The Quran claims that: The prophet is closer to the believers than their own selves, and his wives are their mothers. S. 33:6 The late Muslim translator Abdullah Yusuf Ali records that Ubayy b. Kab,

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamquranhadith

Qur'an Inconsistency: Can I call her mother? Members Public

Qur'an Inconsistency Can I call her mother? The Quran says that a mother is one who gives birth to a person: God has heard the words of her that disputes with thee concerning her husband, and makes complaint unto God. God hears the two of you conversing together;

Jochen Katz
quranislamQur’anic Contradictions

Qur'an Contradiction: Is there a minimum age for marriage? Members Public

Qur'an Contradiction The Age of Marriage Sam Shamoun The Quran, in at least one passage, presupposes that there is an age which a girl must attain before she can be considered marriageable: And try orphans (as regards their intelligence) until they reach the age of marriage; if then

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
quranislamQur’anic Contradictions

Qur'an Contradiction: How the Islamic Doctrine of Intercession undermines Allah's Omniscience Members Public

Quran Difficulty How the Islamic Doctrine of Intercession undermines Allahs Omniscience Sam Shamoun In some previous articles (1, 2) we discussed the problems and contradictions concerning the Islamic concept of intercession. We saw how the Quran and Islamic literature contradict themselves in that certain references say that Allah does not

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
allahislamquran

On the Integrity of the Qur'an Members Public

On the Integrity of the Qur'an (2) The text of the Glorious Qur'an has been perfectly preserved from the time of Muhammad to the present. The Qur'an is completely free from error. Nothing has been added and nothing has been taken away." So

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
islamquranhadith

On the Integrity of tbe Qur'an Members Public

On the Integrity of the Qur'an (1) "So well has it (the Qur'an) been preserved both in memory and in writing, that the Arabic text we have today is identical to the text as it was revealed to the Prophet. Not even a single letter

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
quranislamcanon

Talking with Muslims about Qur'an Contradictions Members Public

A web page and a personal dialog need very different approaches. The big handicap of a web page is that I cannot lead a dialog but have to present my whole case in a monolog. Since I am not able to respond to the agreement or disagreement of my dialog

Sam Shamoun
Sam Shamoun
quranislamhadith
Get Updates