hadith
Critical examinations of hadith literature, transmission, contradictions, reliability, and theological implications in Islam.
Muhammad's cruel treatment of the Uraynians Paid Members Public
Muhammad's treatment of the Uraynians revisited Sam Shamoun This a response to Bassam Zawadi (*; *) regarding Muhammad's brutal treatment of the Uraynians. Zawadi begins his rebuttal by showing that he doesn't know what a red herring is: Sam Shamoun wrote a 16 page response to
Rebuttal to Shabir Ally: Shabir Ally's Favorite Questions Paid Members Public
Some of Shabir Ally's Favorite Questions Sam Shamoun The following article discusses some of the points that Shabir Ally tries to use against the Holy Bible in his debates and writings. Shabir on Piercing Hebrew Servants Shabir claims that the Bible commands Hebrew servants that wanted to devote
SAI’S RESPONSE TO MY POST Paid Members Public
MUHAMMAD THE BORROWER – DEBATE 2 WITH SAIFULLAH NOTE: Saifullah’s post writings are in blue. When he quotes me, my words are in red. My post writings are in black. When I quote Saifullah, his words will be in blue. Quotes from various authors will be in green. NOTE: I
Introduction to the Index of Hadith Paid Members Public
INTRODUCTION TO THE INDEX OF HADITH Some time ago I began to read through the collections of Hadith. I began to make an index of the Hadith that pertained to a topic of interest to me. This index is not comprehensive. You will find more entries say on Aisha, than
Rebuttals to "It is Truth" Paid Members Public
Responses to "It is Truth" Chapter 3 Stages of the Creation of Man (A) This chapter begins with theology and metaphysical claims concerning Muhammad which have nothing to do with science. The authors of this chapter attempt to extricate Muhammad from the fact that he, according to the
Locical Fallacies of Muslim Apologetics Paid Members Public
Preservation and Truth Often times my question "How do you know the Qur'an is from God?" is met by Muslims with a response like this: * No disrespect intended but I really don't see how you can make a stronger claim for the Bible to
Did Ibn Abbas Believe that the Holy Bible was Corrupt? Paid Members Public
Did Ibn Abbas Believe that the Holy Bible was Corrupt? Sam Shamoun Sahih al-Bukhari records Muhammad's first cousin and close companion Ibn Abbas, considered one of the greatest Islamic scholars of all time, making the claim that all of God's revealed Books remain uncorrupted. He
Helping Answering Islam Paid Members Public
Helping Answering Islam You probably came to this page because you want to respond to one or more of Answering Islam's help requests — by sharing information, suggesting further links for our pages, offering an article or testimony for publication on our site, telling us about your desire to