hadith
Critical examinations of hadith literature, transmission, contradictions, reliability, and theological implications in Islam.
INVOKING MUHAMMAD: MAN IN NEED & THE BLIND MAN Paid Members Public
The following lengthy extract is taken from ENGLISH BOOK: Counter refutation on topic of Waseela By Aamir Ibrahim, pp. 41-77. The author provides a thorough refutation to the attempt by Salafi Muslims to weaken the narrations where a blind man and a man in need prayed to Muhammad directly,
MUSLIMS MUST WORSHIP THE SON Paid Members Public
In this post I will prove from the Muslim scripture that Muhammadans must worship Jesus as God’s Son. The Quranic Challenge Muhammad is made to say that if his deity has a son then he would be the first to worship and serve him: Say: ‘If the All-merciful
AISHA: THE SEMEN SCRAPER Paid Members Public
According to the allegedly sound narrations of Sunni Islam, Muhammad’s child-bride Aisha is reported to have stated that she not only saw her husband wash semen off his clothes with water, but that she herself would either wash or scrape off Muhammad’s semen stains with her nails.
TO SIT OR NOT SIT: ALLAH’S DILEMMA! Paid Members Public
The Quran claims that it is a scripture that explains everything in detail, providing a complete exposition of its verses: [Say (O Muhammad)] “Shall I seek a judge other than Allah while it is He Who has sent down unto you the Book (The Qur’an), explained in detail.” Those
THE HADITHIC MUHAMMAD PT. 2 Paid Members Public
Here’s the remaining part of More’s section on the hadithic Muhammad: THE HADITHIC MUHAMMAD PT. 1. Section IV. On Jihad (Holy War) The Hadith reveals that Muhammad wanted his religion to be spread primarily by the sword. It is filled with commands to make war upon non-Muslims
A Coptic Convert Exposes Muhammad Pt. 5 Paid Members Public
I come to the finale in this series: A Coptic Convert Exposes Muhammad Pt. 4. CONTRADICTIONS GALORE As I stated previously, Ibn Raja’s knowledge and mastery of the Islamic sources are simply amazing. This will be further confirmed here by his awareness of all the irreconcilable contradictions within the
A Coptic Convert Exposes Muhammad Pt. 4 Paid Members Public
I share another installment in this series: A Coptic Convert Exposes Muhammad Pt. 3 . THE CORRUPT QURAN Ibn Raja shows extraordinary knowledge and mastery of what the Islamic sources claim in respect to the composition, variations and corruption of the Quran I excerpt pp. 153-173 of David Bertaina’s
A Coptic Convert Exposes Muhammad Pt. 3 Paid Members Public
This is another installment from a series of posts from the Coptic convert Ibn Rajal: A Coptic Convert Exposes Muhammad Pt. 2. In this section I quote what this blessed monk wrote in respect to the manner in which Muhammad allegedly received inspiration. Ibn Rajal exposes Muhammad as a charlatan