Comparative Index to Islam : MOON GOD

MOON GOD

Currently, there is an ongoing debate as to whether the Allah of the Qur'an is in fact a pagan Arab moon god of pre-Islamic times. The idea has been mentioned in literature for more than a century, but only recently has the theory been seriously promoted. The theory is briefly presented in some of Dr. Robert Morey's books and pamphlets written since 1991.

Most academic theories are discussed for decades before they are either abandoned as dead ends or adopted as truth. The proponents and opponents of this theory both readily admit they are awaiting further research and archaeology to vindicate their claims. Many have resorted to making hasty accusations in testy debates. This may make it difficult to distinguish between what is fact and what is pure rhetoric. We, however, invite the reader to take a scholarly "wait and see" approach to this subject.

Here are some online pages arguing pro and contra:

(The list of such pages, both pro and contra, used to be much longer, but many of them have disappeared in recent months.)

The most relevant online articles that are currently known to us:

• Bogus Quotations Concerning Allah Being a Pre-Islamic Moon God.
• Reply To Robert Morey's Moon-God Myth: A Look At The Archaeological Evidence is the most thorough Muslim response to the moon god theory (containing even a reference to this page), but ...
• Whether Moon-gods Were The High-gods In South Arabian Religions by Yoel Natan questions their interpretation of the available evidence. These two articles should be studied together.
• Is Allah = Hubal = Baal? This hypothesis is discussed in the article Ishmaelites and the Worship of God.

Related articles

• Is the Quran An Implicit Endorsement and Continuation of Arab Paganism?

Go Back to Main Index